Joe Vary: Gardening for a better future

From his origins in the North-East, Joe has moved steadily southwards: to Wisley, then to the Buckingham Palace garden and now to very near us, at Wickhambreaux. He operates as a ‘gardening mentor’ as well as a gardener and designer, and on this evening, which began with the sound of church bells and ended with that of a a deluge outside, he treated us to an unusual presentation, by turns alarming and optimistic, in which our gardens were situated in the wider ecological context. More than that, gardens, he told us, can and do play a vital role in keeping biodiversity alive. Gardens have been overlooked by developers, ecologists, policy-makers and ourselves in this role.
He began by assailing us with some statistical information, some of which drew gasps of astonishment from the audience. For instance, out of 240 countries, the UK ranks in 189th place for ‘nature intactness’; only 16% of English rivers meet good ecological status; 97% of wildflower meadows has gone since the 1930s, and these are the richest and most biodiverse ecosystems that we have. Over half of our wildflower species have gone since the 1970s, taking with them the pollinating insects that depend on them (down 18%) and the other insect species that predate them (down 34%). With fewer predators, we get more pests, leading to the use of more pesticides – which also wipe out the remaining predators, with insects that specialise in particular plants or which are especially sensitive to the chemicals, like butterflies (down 80% since the 1970s) especially vulnerable. With the decline in insects comes a decline in birds that feed on them: swifts, for instance (down 68%), along with spotted flycatchers (67%), yellowhammers (58%) and turtledoves (98%). Of our native bird species, 43% are threatened with extinction; mammals, 25%.
Of the range of causal factors in the loss of biodiverse habitats, Joe emphasised one in particular: farming. An aerial view of the village he lives in makes the point: it is is an island in a sea of industrialised farmland, with large fields of monoculture and polytunnels. Pastureland or fields with a single crop cannot support wildlife, and the latter are subjected to regular applications of chemicals: fertilisers and pesticides. With regular ploughing as well, the soil is effectively dead. And Wickhambreaux is not exceptional; rather, is it typical of the 70% of the British land area that is taken up by farmland. Of course, we need farms to produce food. So the question arises, how can we mitigate the damage that agriculture inevitably does to our wildlife?
From an animal’s perspective, they are not going to head for the ‘green deserts’ of the farmer’s field. They will go to what is, for them, a more welcoming environment: our gardens. These have hedges, which protect from the elements and could mean food, shelter, a place to breed and so on. A well cared for garden is a functioning ecosystem. There’s a greater diversity of plants than there are in the fields, feeding pollinating insects and herbivores, some of which – caterpillars, slugs and snails for instance – we regard as pests, but for other species are a resource.
Joe told us about Jennifer Owen, a zoologist who moved into her suburban home in Leicester in 1972. “Gardens”, she wrote, “are extraordinarily rich habitats,” and over the next 30 years she proved it. She recorded every species she observed in her garden: 474 species of plant, 64 of vertebrates, 1997 insect species, 138 other invertebrates – and out of all these 2673 species, seven had never been found in Britain before. Most gardens, she pointed out, must harbour a similarly diverse range of life. Sheffield University, inspired by Owen’s work, started the Biodiversity in Urban Gardens Sheffield (BUGS) project, and in a much shorter time also found over 2,000 species of plants and animals.
England’s gardens occupy an area three times the size of the Lake District. It is a national park we never knew we had, and the most biodiverse of all, but it is fragmented, and fragmented ecosystems become fragile. A few simple actions can help mitigate this; Joe ran us through five.
- Wilding the garden. This is a powerful one, because our wildlife evolved in our natural landscapes. So we can recreate part of this in the garden. The old view that Britain was once covered in forest is probably wrong; some of it was more open, with bushes, small trees and grassland. This means that garden wilding should not be difficult. Establishing a meadow involves just stopping mowing in March, then cutting it down in late Summer, removing the clippings. This enables wild flowers to compete with the grass; their seeds will find their way into the garden. Let the ‘weeds’ grow. Flowers attract pollinators, and insects attract their predators. Other habitats that we can mimic include ponds, open canopy woodland in large gardens and making the biggest part of the garden wilder.
- Naturalistic planting. Piet Oudolf, one of the most influential gardeners of modern times, showed how to do this using a wide variety of cultivated plants. It is not wild, but naturalistic, and makes a habitat for wildlife. Joe introduced us to the ‘four Ds’ as a guide to starting naturalistic planting. Dense: you shouldn’t be able to see the soil. Diverse: using plants from different groups promotes resilience and provides support for pollinators over a long season. Durable: use plants you can depend on. Dies beautifully: use those that have good seed heads and structure; they are beautiful, even in Winter, and again, good for wildlife.
- Homes for wildlife, to replace those lost to agriculture. Hedgerows are artificial homes and support many species, but half have gone in the last 100 years. Fences are not, so plant a hedge instead of a fence – and make it a mixed hedge, made up of different varieties. Bee and bug hotels, bird boxes and log piles also help. Only 4% of modern farm buildings are usable by barn owls, compared to 50% of traditional buildings, so nest boxes for them are good, if you have the space. Ponds support up to 2/3 of our freshwater species. They can be ‘stepping stones’ between aquatic habitats.
- Harnessing natural resources. Turn garden waste into compost – pile it up, using as much as you can, and chop it up with some grass clippings in Spring. It will heat up, then cool down; turn it, and it will do so again. After three or four such cycles you will have good compost. Plants themselves are another resource which can be used to promote soil health. As you need lots of them, you will need efficient propagation: use seed collection and sowing (your own and others’), cuttings and dividing at the roots.
- Change of mindset. Perhaps the most important, but also the most difficult, because it means encouraging and persuading other people. This is happening in some places, e.g. Wisley has adopted Oudolf’s naturalistic approach, and they don’t mow the arboretum any more. And millions of people visit RHS gardens every year.
The final message, to sum up, is that even small gardens can play an important part in supporting nature, and the more that do so, the bigger that support will be.
Ken Manktelow